Chibi: A True Story from Japan
Tadpole Update

Mr. Putter & Tabby Spin the Yarn

I'm a little torn about the movie version of Mr. Putter & Tabby Spin the Yarn (Harcourt, 2006). I'm tempted to cast Tim Conway and Carol Burnett for the central roles of elderly Mr. Putter and his good (and also elderly) neighbor, Mrs. Teaberry, but I worry that they wouldn't be able to play it straight. They might, you know, start laughing, because this is a funny book. But it's a funny book that doesn't let on that it's funny; ..Spin the Yarn leaves it up to the reader, who will just know. So, for that reason, I'm calling on Bob Hoskins and Dame Judi Dench, who are more than capable of reserve. Zeke, Mrs. Teaberry's sweet mess of a dog, will be played by the skateboarding bulldog on YouTube. I'm not sure yet about Tabby, Mr. Putter's lovable cat. The Morris the Cat types have too much self-confidence.  In Arthur Howard's illustrations, Tabby often looks rattled.

If you don't know what I'm talking about, you need to get a hold of the latest in Cynthia Rylant's series of easy readers. To me, the book is right up there with Mr. Putter & Tabby Feed the Fish, in which Tabby cannot contain herself over some new goldfish. She must bat at them. She must. She gets carried away batting. By my count, there are 15 books in the series so far, and a new one,  Mr. Putter & Tabby See the Stars, hits the stores in August, according to Powell's. (How come nobody throws a party for that, huh? I'd line up at midnight.)

In Mr. Putter & Tabby Spin the Yarn, Mrs. Teaberry starts a knitting club. Because he is worried that he is not a good neighbor (and always eating treats that Mrs. Teaberry makes without reciprocating), Mr. Putter announces that he will serve the knitting club tea. This is typical of Mr. Putter, whose good ideas often lead to adventure, if not chaos. There's an unexpected quality to the dialogue that I admire. (James Marshall's Fox series shares this.) Upon entering Mrs. Teaberry's house to start the tea-making, Mr. Putter encounters the following:

Everyone said a cheery hello to Mr. Putter and Tabby. "Where's Zeke?" asked Mr. Putter. "I closed him in the kitchen," said Mrs. Teaberry. "He was bothering Gertrude's hat."

On the next page, we see Arthur Howard's picture of Gertrude's monstrosity of a hat, which is ringed by plastic vegetables. Of course the sweet lunatic Zeke would want a piece of that. Tabby, meanwhile, spots numerous balls of yarn/prey, and her teeth begin to chatter with desire. (Our cat does that when he sees a squirrel.) Needless to say, "excitement" follows. My son laughed his way through the book, and so did I.

I put the Mr. Putter & Tabby series between Frog and Toad and Magic Tree House books in terms of difficulty. The challenging easy readers feature 18 point type, plenty of white space between the lines, short lines, no more than eight words a line, four short chapters, and, always, cheerful homage to friendship and love. From experience I can tell you that they make good read-alouds for younger children and that more experienced readers still enjoy returning to the books. Arthur Howard's illustrations work hand in hand with the text, letting a young reader see what Rylant means by the words "tea cozy," for example.

Easy readers don't get enough attention in the press. Sure, series like this sell themselves; many school libraries and reading resource rooms at elementary schools contain lots of Mr. Putter & Tabby books. But unless you're a teacher or librarian or read one of the trade magazines, you don't necessarily hear much about the genre other than the Dr. Seuss books and a few others. From time to time I will try to highlight some good ones. Meanwhile, I must get back to casting the movie. Good books can inspire that in a person.

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

You can not imagine how much my family loves Mr. Putter and Tabby. I agree with you about Tim Conway and Carol Burnett. I used to love to watch them try to play it straight. They would be perfect if there was ever a movie version. We don't have Spin the Yarn. I will have to get it.

What I like about these books is that they are not torturous to sit through 20 or 30 times. There are some books that the children love, but I cannot bear. There are a few that I try to hide. Putter and Tabby books are just as good on the 20th reading.

I agree, Wisteria--you can listen to or read them aloud many times over. (I can't bear to read The Cat in the Hat--drives me crazy.) I wonder if anyone ever wrote a theatrical version of Mr. Putter...

My family is also part of the Mr. Putter and Tabby fan club. I love how this series depicts elderly people both tenderly and with humor. And I'm with you, Susan, that easy readers are under covered. My daughter was a struggling reader, and these books were so helpful for many years. Now we read them for the fun of visiting with quirky, loveable old friends.

One more thing. I think Angela Lansbury might pull off a fine Mrs. Teaberry too.

Angela Lansbury, oh, ho. She would be good, too, Rose.

In the fall I'm going to take a couple of the books to read aloud to the first-graders at the school where I volunteer. I think the kids would like them.

I've never understood why Henry and Mudge is more popular than Mr. Putter and Tabby, since they're equally good. It's rare that I run across a Rylant that I *don't* like, and it's much the same with Arthur Howard's illustrations. (I particularly love his picture book, Hoodwinked.)

Adrienne, I haven't seen Hoodwinked. Thanks for the tip.

Can you believe how prolific Cynthia Rylant is?

I adore Mr. Putter and Tabby. I am so glad to hear there is a new one! Thanks for this great review.

It is amazing how prolific Rylant is, especially considering that most of her stuff is really good. I keep thinking, "Well, this will probably be the stinker," but I've never read anything of hers that I haven't enjoyed.

Of course, she seems to never be at conferences or lectures. That kind of thing is a big part of most children's authors' lives, so I guess if you cut that out, you have plenty more time to write. I guess she's in a place where she doesn't have to over-worry promoting herself.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)